I accused him of being a baby for complaining about me hitting him when he was trying to get through the door. 2023 CNET, a Red Ventures company. Judge Penney Azcarate excused jurors for the long Memorial Day . Pictured, Azcarate speaks during a hearing at the Fairfax County Circuit Courthouse in Fairfax, Virginia, on May 3, 2022. ugly details of their tumultuous marriage, social media, which has played a huge role in the public perception of the trial, Everyone Practices Cancel Culture | Opinion, Deplatforming Free Speech is Dangerous | Opinion. Depp supporters outside court on Friday. The jury awarded Heard $2 million in compensatory damages, but $0 in punitive damages. It shows who we believe, how we believe, and thelengths people go to convince themselves their beliefs are true. Heard alleges that while on a vacation with Depp in May 2013, he did a "cavity search" on her while looking for his cocaine. The jury has awarded Depp $15 million and Heard $2 million. In a video shown in court, Johnny Depp is seen pacing in an elevator after a fight with Amber Heard on May 21, 2016. In June 2022, the long legal battle between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard finally reached a verdict, years after the former Pirates of the Caribbean actor and his The Rum Diary co-star first filed . Mr Depp threw a wine bottle across the hotel room in one instance, while we were shooting Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. Were [also] seeing bigger and bigger audiences on Twitch, she added. After the ruling, Depp posts a statement on Instagram saying he had been asked to exit the "Fantastic Beasts" franchise. Heard told the court she did not call 911 during the 2016 argument and chose not to cooperate with police because she feared they might arrest Depp, whom she was trying to protect. The jury determined that Heard acted with actual malice when writing her op-ed. The civil trial between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard continued Tuesday as Heard's legal team rested its case. The jury, comprised of seven members and two alternates, returns to deliberations on May 31 after the Memorial Day holiday. Reactions to the case online and off from TikTok videos to Depp's giggling trial audience to the people taunting Heard as she walks into court are colored by biases, assumptions and personal experiences. A fter six weeks of testimony from Johnny Depp and Amber Heard's legal teams, both sides delivered closing arguments today, and jury deliberations began. Depp . Experts in domestic violence say toxic, unhealthy relationships can include bidirectional violence with no primary aggressor, and abusive relationships with a primary aggressor can include victims who use violence as self-defense or as a way to try and reassert control. Highest Grossing Hindi Dubbed South Films. Horrible. He told the court that Heard followed him around several rooms in the rented Australia home as he attempted to escape the argument, until he began drinking in the bar area of the residence. The Depp Heard controversy did not end with that civil divorce settlement as in the February of 2019, Johnny Depp sued his ex-wife Amber Heard for defamation through a piece . Depp is suing Heard for $50 million, claiming she defamed him in a 2018 Washington Post op-ed where she referred to herself as a public figure representing domestic abuse. According to Pizarro's framework, if someone makes the moral judgment that Depp is likely an example of a man falsely accused, they will look for information that confirms that beliefand evaluate it less carefully than the information that disproves it, which they have to work harder to dismiss. Heard's new team is led by David Shane. Johnny Depp's sensational defamation trial against ex-wife Amber Heard wrapped . In the defense's opening statement, attorney J. Benjamin Rottenborn reads the entirety of Heard's Post op-ed to the jury, and tells them that the actor exercised her right to free speech. She describes other instances of alleged abuse, including the time Depp allegedly first hit her. The jury awarded Heard $2 million in compensatory damages but $0 in punitive damages. The trial usually runs on a Monday-Thursday schedule. Each claim was worth $50 million in damages. Hughes's testimony did not appear to provide any pendulum effect, at least on social media. Saba Hamedy is the culture and trends editor for NBC News Digital. Johnny Depp sits in the courtroom during the Depp vs Heard defamation trial at the Fairfax County Circuit Court in Fairfax, Virginia, on April 14, 2022. To explain her beatings, she said that her [] ". They just don't want to be wrong.". During the first day of her testimony on May 4, Heard paints a picture of a man who oscillated between active addiction and sobriety, which she said made it hard to continue the relationship. This includes avoiding TV, news and social media, which has played a huge role in the public perception of the trial thus far. Also among the witnesses to testify on Thursday was Tracey Jacobs, Johnny Depps former agent. "What you learn about this case is limited to what you learn in the four walls of this courtroom when proceedings are underway, OK?" For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. I did a lot of changing to support his sobriety. Depp denied the incident, saying he went to the couples penthouse the day after his mother died to speak to Heard about his desire to file for divorce. I would get yelled at. Depp sued for $50 million in damages over a 2018 opinion-editorial essay in The Washington Post, in which Heard said she had become a public figure representing domestic abuse., Watch jury award Johnny Depp $15 million in defamation suit against Amber Heard, 2018 opinion-editorial essay by Heard in The Washington Post, Depp's lawyers say claims against actor were defamatory and unsupported by any evidence, Amber Heard 'heartbroken' after jury sides with Johnny Depp in defamation case. Penny Azcarate said that sufficient evidence had been presented by . In a virtual deposition, Barkin said that during the several months the pair were together, Depp "was drunk most of the time". Johnny Depp won a defamation suit Wednesday against his former wife Amber Heard after a jury found that she had defamed Depp in saying that he had abused her over the course of their relationship. Ltd. All Rights Reserved, When Ashton Kutcher Admitted Being In Friends With Benefits With Mila Kunis Much Like Their Film, It Was Funny Because Id Just Done This Movie, When Robert Downey Jr. The same process occurs for the person who makes the moral judgment Heard is likely an abused woman denigrated by the culture when she should be believed. The pair divorced in August 2016. The Depp-Heard trial. A lifelong fan of memes (and writing), she's currently in her dream gig. Heard denied ever staging or doctoring photos in her abuse allegations. Meanwhile, Heard's team told Newsweek: "One of Ms. Heard's disappointments is Mr. Depp's inability to distinguish fact from fictiona malady which appears to have spread to his legal team. Heardhas filed a $100 millioncountersuit. "We bring our own thoughts and ideas, and our personal experiences as well. Heard testified that the hit occurred when she was defending herself against Depp and that the audio was recorded in a verbal argument about the matter later. Last month, the jury in the case found overwhelmingly in Depp's favor that Heard defamed him when she published acolumn in The Washington Post in December 2018 calling herself a victim of domestic abuse. Depps legal team submitted numerous audio recordings of the couples arguments into evidence, one file of which included Heard seemingly admitting to having hit Depp while simultaneously denying that she punched him. Experts say it's a dangerous moment for domestic violence. Unimaginably brutal. During opening statements, Depp lawyer Benjamin Chew said Heard's article clearly referred to Depp, and that Heard's "false allegations had a significant impact on Mr. Depp's family and his ability to work in the profession he loved. "The question about why we see different things in this case is deeply influenced by the moral judgment that we make first. ", "Though understandably displeased at the outcome of the trial, Ms. Heard has identified no legitimate basis to set aside in any respect the jury's decision," Depp's lawyers argued in their brief. Others are also tuning in on YouTube, withLaw & Crimes Stockman telling Axios: Consumption has changed for trials like this. "There is no evidence of fraud or wrongdoing", Through one of his lawyers, Benjamin Chew, Depp said he was "most gratified by the Courts rulings.. Savage. Depp is suing for $50 million, while Heard has countersued for $100 million, arguing that a Depp lawyer's claims to the Daily Mail that she was staging a "hoax" were defamatory. She said in the article that she'd become "a public figure representing domestic abuse" but didn't mention Depp's name. Judge Penney Azcarate adjourned the Johnny Depp v. Amber Heard trial on May 5 and the trial will not resume until May 16. ", Depp said that "the jury gave me my life back. Depp's team asks Circuit Court JudgePenney Azcarate to dismiss Heard's countersuit, which was unsuccessful. Audio of Heard allegedly saying she hit Depp is published by The Daily Mail. Why does Amber Heard call Johnny Depp Steve in love notes read in the trial? "It's unsurprising that the people who were on the front-end really excited to tweet about it, to make TikToks about it, to create an entire following about it are the ones who are going to have the least amount of personal experience with this type of violence," Bedera said. Theres no way in or out.. Her experience is reminiscent of other cases where women were publicly scorned and later reevaluated, including Lorena Bobbitt, Monica Lewinsky, Anita HillandBritney Spears. When asked about the first time Depp allegedly hit her, Heard described an instance when she'd asked Depp about what one of his tattoos said, and he'd replied "wino." Heard initially alleged in 2016 when she filed for a protective order that Depp bruised her after he threw a phone at her. They argue there's too much energy spent analyzing how this event fits into the culture, reflects it and refracts it. Original filing:Amber Heard files to dismiss verdict or grant retrial in Johnny Depp defamation case. On Thursday, the court heard from witnesses such as Johnny Depps former friend Bruce Witkin; Depps former co-star and girlfriend Ellen Barkin; and his ex-agent, Tracey Jacobs. Heard filed a countersuit against Depp, which was decided as part of the trial. Experts say the trial highlights structural problems in media reporting, in the power of social media platforms, in the way gender inequality is addressed, in the way the justice system may become weaponized, in the way we all become complicit in retraumatizing people who have experienced profound harm.